This story is from July 27, 2018
Similar trademarks for different items not breach of law: SC
NEW DELHI: In a landmark decision in the field of trademarks, the Supreme Court ruled on Thursday that it was no infringement of law if two distinctly different products were marketed by two different companies with "deceptively similar" trademarks.
A decade-old trademark infringement case between Karnataka Cooperative Milk Producers Association, which has been marketing milk and milk products under the trademark 'Nandini' since 1985, and a group adopting the name 'Nandhini' for its restaurant and food products business in 1989, continued through the Registrar of Trademarks, Intellectual Property Appellate Board and Karnataka high court. With the board and the HC restraining the restaurant chain from using the 'Nandhini' trademark, the battle shifted to the SC in 2015.
A bench of Justices AK Sikri and Ashok Bhushan distinguished the products for which the deceptively similar trademarks were used. While 'Nandini' was for milk, milk products, cattle feed and other allied commodities, the 'Nandhini' trademark was for meat, fish, poultry, meat extracts, preserves, dried and cooked fruits and vegetables, jellies, jams, eggs, milk and milk products, edible oils and fats, salad dressings etc.
What eased the complex task for the court was the restaurant chain's decision to give up its claim for 'Nandhini' trademark on milk and milk products. The court said, "Nandini/Nandhini is a generic name, representing a goddess and a cow in Hindu mythology, and it is not an invented or coined word by anyone to the dispute."
A decade-old trademark infringement case between Karnataka Cooperative Milk Producers Association, which has been marketing milk and milk products under the trademark 'Nandini' since 1985, and a group adopting the name 'Nandhini' for its restaurant and food products business in 1989, continued through the Registrar of Trademarks, Intellectual Property Appellate Board and Karnataka high court. With the board and the HC restraining the restaurant chain from using the 'Nandhini' trademark, the battle shifted to the SC in 2015.
A bench of Justices AK Sikri and Ashok Bhushan distinguished the products for which the deceptively similar trademarks were used. While 'Nandini' was for milk, milk products, cattle feed and other allied commodities, the 'Nandhini' trademark was for meat, fish, poultry, meat extracts, preserves, dried and cooked fruits and vegetables, jellies, jams, eggs, milk and milk products, edible oils and fats, salad dressings etc.
What eased the complex task for the court was the restaurant chain's decision to give up its claim for 'Nandhini' trademark on milk and milk products. The court said, "Nandini/Nandhini is a generic name, representing a goddess and a cow in Hindu mythology, and it is not an invented or coined word by anyone to the dispute."
Top Comment
Ramachandra Venkatachala
2072 days ago
A balanced view by SC. This can help many such fights/ cases across the country. In particular, the remarks of Hon. Judges that a common name like Nandini is not invented by anyone; hence it can not be appropriated by any Company or organisation to have sole rights over its usage..Read allPost comment
Popular from India
- I-T serves Congress Rs 1, 700 crore notice after HC rejects its plea on reassessment
- PM Narendra Modi and Bill Gates interact on AI, climate change, and women empowerment: Key points
- 'Hope that everyone's rights are protected': UN on Arvind Kejriwal's arrest, freezing of Congress bank accounts
- Tejas MK-1A completes maiden flight, first delivery soon
- ‘Why must married women ask government or ex to retain their maiden name?’
end of article
Expand
Trending Stories
- IPL 2024 in USA: How to watch Royal Challengers Bengaluru vs Kolkata Knight Riders IPL 2024 live streaming in the USA
- Bihar Board 10th Result 2024 Live: BSEB Matric results likely tomorrow at biharboardonline.com, steps to download
- IPL 2024 Points Table and Team Rankings After RR vs DC Match
- I-T serves Congress Rs 1, 700 crore notice after HC rejects its plea on reassessment
- PM Narendra Modi and Bill Gates interact on AI, climate change, and women empowerment: Key points
- Bengaluru cafe blast: Co-conspirator held after 4 wks
- Mukhtar Ansari's reign of terror: First case at 17, first conviction at 61
Visual Stories
- 8 light yet healthy snacks for a speedy weight loss
- 8 house rules that every parent should teach their child
- How to make South Indian Lemon Coconut Rice at home
- How to make South-Indian style Mutton Curry
- 10 quickest animals that race across the Earth
UP NEXT