Farmers Suicides In India - Indian Streams Research Journal
Farmers Suicides In India - Indian Streams Research Journal
Farmers Suicides In India - Indian Streams Research Journal
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
<strong>Research</strong> Paper - Economics<br />
<strong>Farmers</strong> <strong>Suicides</strong> <strong>In</strong> <strong>In</strong>dia<br />
Vol. 1, Issue . 1 / February 2011, pp. 113-117<br />
- Dr. P. V. Deshmukh<br />
Dept. of Economics,<br />
Dr. Babasaheb Amedkar Marathwada<br />
University, Aurangabad<br />
Agriculture sector has a pivotal role in<br />
<strong>In</strong>dian economy. The share of agriculture<br />
sector in G.D.P. of <strong>In</strong>dia was 44.0% during<br />
1973-74 .Agriculture provides the principal<br />
means of livelihood for over 60 percent of<br />
<strong>In</strong>dia's population. There a significant increase<br />
in production between 1951-52 to 1959-1960<br />
was due to favorable monsoons and<br />
expansion of acreage not yield. <strong>In</strong> <strong>In</strong>dian<br />
planning agriculture sector ignored except few<br />
five years plan. <strong>In</strong>dian planning has not be<br />
given appropriate priority to agriculture.<br />
There are lot of limitations for protection to<br />
agriculture in new economics policy. <strong>In</strong><br />
globalization era grant in aid of agriculture<br />
were drawn and in other hand import of<br />
agricultural products allowed without<br />
restrictions at large amount. <strong>In</strong> the processes of<br />
industrialization there are drastic changes in<br />
climate , due to this agriculture productivity<br />
suffered . Banking sector is not ready to<br />
provide credit /loan to Agriculture for avoiding<br />
risk .<strong>Farmers</strong> were trapped by private debt .<br />
Maharashtra is suffering with same problem<br />
.Maharashtra Government took some decision<br />
tackle this problem. But unfortunately<br />
decisions taken by Maharashtra Government<br />
are not effective because after the legal<br />
provision taken by Government there is no<br />
development in farmer's life. According to<br />
some economist and socialist Agriculture<br />
sector is a bone of <strong>In</strong>dian Economy therefore<br />
farmer's must have some protection but lack<br />
of protection and favorable policies to<br />
agriculture , lead to suicides of farmers at large<br />
On this background, in the present paper I have<br />
focused on the causes of farmer's suicide ,<br />
nature of problem, consequences ,and<br />
remedies.<br />
Causes :<br />
There are various economic ,social ,<br />
political , individual and environmental causes<br />
of farmer's suicide in <strong>In</strong>dia. The causes of this<br />
crisis are complex and manifold, they are<br />
dominantly related to public policy and<br />
economic strategy.<br />
Absence of adequate social support<br />
infrastructure at the level of village.<br />
Uncertainty of agricultural enterprise in<br />
<strong>In</strong>dia.,<br />
<strong>In</strong>debtedness of farmers. Rising cost of<br />
cultivation.<br />
Lack of credit availability for small<br />
farmers. There has been minimal financial<br />
support from the government for small<br />
farmers.<br />
Lack of irrigation facilities.<br />
Lack of Government Vision and clarity of<br />
intention to benefit the poor and small<br />
farmers.<br />
Reduction of agriculture subsidies.<br />
Environmental pollution.<br />
Exploitation of natural resources (water,<br />
<strong>In</strong>dian <strong>Streams</strong> <strong>Research</strong> <strong>Journal</strong> / 113
<strong>Farmers</strong> <strong>Suicides</strong> <strong>In</strong> <strong>In</strong>dia<br />
forest)<br />
Unfavorable international policies.<br />
Lack of increasing in the prices of<br />
agricultural products compare to<br />
agricultural inputs. <strong>In</strong>dian farmers are<br />
facing is the dramatic fall in prices of farm<br />
produce as a result of the WTO's free trade<br />
policies.<br />
Monocultures and uniformity increase the<br />
risk of crop failure , as diverse seeds<br />
adapted to diverse to eco-system are<br />
replaced by the rushed introduction of<br />
uniformity and often untested seeds into<br />
the market. When Monsanto first<br />
introduced Bt Cotton in 2002, the farmers<br />
lost 1 billion rupees due to crop failure.<br />
The drinking habit which atrophies the<br />
productivity of the farmer.<br />
Extravagant expenditure on marriages.<br />
Bad health and illness and inability to<br />
meet the necessary expenditure on<br />
medicine and health services.<br />
Government has destroyed Important<br />
public institutions.<br />
Rehabilitation packages e.g. Package of<br />
Central Government, Package of State<br />
Government, Lone Waiver Proposal, etc<br />
are not implementing in proper way to<br />
relief needy farmers.<br />
Public expenditure on rural development<br />
fell during this period from 14.5 percent to<br />
G.D.P. in 1991 to 5.9 percent I 2004 (P.<br />
Sainath, The Hindu -2/2/2010<br />
<strong>In</strong>tensity of the problem :<br />
There were lot of studies have been done by<br />
various social workers N.G.Os, Economist,<br />
<strong>In</strong>stitutions, journalist ( P.Sainath) ,etc. But<br />
there are different approaches to understand the<br />
nature ,causes and rehabilitation packages<br />
which are announced by governments .The<br />
states Maharashtra , Andhra Pradesh<br />
,Karnataka Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh<br />
are suffering from this problem especially.<br />
According to P.Sainath , the number of farmers<br />
who have committed suicide since 1997 to<br />
2008 in these five state was 122823 and all<br />
<strong>In</strong>dia level was 199132. Prof . Nagraj proved<br />
that the farmers suicide rate was 12.9 between<br />
the period 1997 to 2005 and one farmer<br />
committed suicide every 53 minutes in <strong>In</strong>dia.<br />
On the basis National Crime Records Bureau ,<br />
it is possible that at least two lakh farmers<br />
committed suicide in the last 12 years . Most of<br />
experts are agree with the seriousness of<br />
concern problem .I had tried to focus on<br />
farmer's suicides in <strong>In</strong>dia with some statistics<br />
which are published by various expert<br />
committees and thinkers .<br />
Trends of farmers suicides :<br />
Vol. 1, Issue . 1 / February 2011<br />
T.1: <strong>Farmers</strong> suicides : Big five states and <strong>In</strong>dia<br />
Year Maharashtra Andhra Karnataka Madhya Total of All <strong>In</strong>dia<br />
Pradesh<br />
Pradesh & 5 states<br />
Chhattisgarh<br />
1997 1917 1097 1832 2390 7236 13622<br />
1998 2409 1813 1883 2278 8333 16015<br />
1999 2423 1974 2379 2654 9430 16082<br />
2000 3022 1525 2630 2660 9837 16603<br />
2001 3536 1509 2505 2824 10374 16415<br />
2002 3695 1896 2340 2578 10509 17971<br />
2003 3836 1800 2678 2511 10825 17164<br />
2004 4147 2666 1963 3033 11809 18241<br />
2005 3926 2490 1883 2660 10959 17131<br />
2006 4453 2607 1720 2858 11638 17060<br />
2007 4238 1797 2135 2856 11026 16632<br />
2008 3802 2105 1737 3152 10797 16196<br />
Total 41404 23279 25685 32454 122823 199132<br />
Aver<br />
age<br />
3450.33 1940 2140 2704.5 10235.3 16594.3<br />
Source:www.inditogether.org- Date: 3/11/2010<br />
P. Sainath has focused with above statistics<br />
on farmers suicide in the five big states. <strong>In</strong> the<br />
<strong>In</strong>dian <strong>Streams</strong> <strong>Research</strong> <strong>Journal</strong> / 114
<strong>Farmers</strong> <strong>Suicides</strong> <strong>In</strong> <strong>In</strong>dia Vol. 1, Issue . 1 / February 2011<br />
period from 1997 to 2008 average of farmers<br />
suicide in these five state is 10235.3 per year<br />
and all <strong>In</strong>dia level the average suicides of<br />
farmers suicide is 16594.3. Maharashtra is<br />
known by progressive and developed state but<br />
in other side number of farmers suicide is<br />
maximum in <strong>In</strong>dia because the average of<br />
farmers suicides in Maharashtra is 3450.33<br />
which is more than other four states due to<br />
failure of cotton crops and increasing debt<br />
during the period 1997-2008.<br />
State-wise distribution of farm suicides :<br />
All states of <strong>In</strong>dia are facing the<br />
problem of farm suicides. We can get idea of<br />
state-wise number of farmers committing<br />
suicides with the 2001 Census.<br />
T2 : State-wise number and rate of farmers<br />
suicides (2001)<br />
Sr.<br />
No<br />
State<br />
Number of suicides<br />
Among<br />
farmers<br />
Among all<br />
population<br />
% of farm<br />
suicide to<br />
total suicide<br />
Suicide rate (per 100000 members)<br />
Among <strong>Farmers</strong><br />
<strong>In</strong> general<br />
population<br />
With all<br />
cultivator<br />
With only<br />
main<br />
cultivator<br />
1 Maharashtra 3536 14618 24.2 15.1 29.9 34.7<br />
2 Karnataka 2505 11881 21.1 22.5 36.4 40.5<br />
3 Andhra P 1509 10522 14.3 13.8 19.2 20.4<br />
4 Chhattisgarh 1452 4025 36.1 19.4 33.7 41.6<br />
5 Madhya P. 1372 6860 20.0 11.4 12.4 14.4<br />
6 West Bengal 1246 13690 9.1 17.1 22.0 27.3<br />
7 Kerala 1035 9572 10.8 30.1 142.9 176.5<br />
8 Tamil Nadu 985 11290 8.7 18.1 19.3 20.8<br />
9 Uttar P. 709 3827 18.5 202 3.0 3.7<br />
10 Gujarat 594 4791 12.4 9.5 10.2 12.6<br />
11 Rajasthan 505 3195 15.8 5.7 3.8 5.3<br />
12 Orissa 256 4052 6.3 11.0 6.0 7.5<br />
13 Assam 167 2647 6.3 9.9 4.5 6.2<br />
14 Haryana 145 2007 7.2 9.5 4.8 6.5<br />
15 Pondicherry 91 529 17.2 54.3 834.9 865.8<br />
16 Bihar 88 853 10.3 0.8 0.7 0.9<br />
17 Punjab 45 648 6.9 2.7 2.2 2.4<br />
18 Tripura 41 854 4.8 26.7 13.1 16.2<br />
19 Himachal P. 22 307 7.2 5.1 1.1 2.0<br />
20 Goa 18 256 7.0 19.0 35.7 60.7<br />
21 Jammu & 15 153 9.8 1.5 0.9 1.6<br />
Kashmir<br />
All <strong>In</strong>dia 16415 108506 15.2 10.6 12.9 15.8<br />
C.V.(%) 116.3 93.4 - 82.3 299.0 280.6<br />
Maximum states are facing this problem<br />
at different level. Maharashtra is a progressive<br />
state but unfortunately Maharashtra was a<br />
leading state in farm suicides in 2001.The<br />
coefficient of variation of farms suicide was<br />
more than general suicides in <strong>In</strong>dia. The<br />
farmers suicide rates were very high compare<br />
to general suicide rate .It is noted that suicide<br />
rate of only main cultivator was high in all<br />
states. State-wise position of suicides in other<br />
state in critical was Andhra Pradesh ,Karnataka<br />
and Madhya Pradesh. According to Prof.<br />
Nagraj on an average one farmer took his life<br />
every 53 minutes between 1997-2005.<br />
according to another study on an average there<br />
has been one farmer's suicide every 32 minutes<br />
since 2002.<strong>In</strong> <strong>In</strong>dia 86.5 percent of farmers<br />
who took their own lives were financially<br />
indebted during 1997 to 2002 (www.un.org-<br />
21/11/2010).<br />
Consequences :.<br />
The government must amend laws that are<br />
governing the farmers in the <strong>In</strong>dian agricultural<br />
sector. If the government does not make any<br />
urgent recommendations or legal provisions to<br />
offer relief to the trend of farmer suicide in the<br />
affected states, the whole country will suffer<br />
the consequences. Some of these are given<br />
below:<br />
* National disaster as farmer suicides<br />
increase every day.<br />
* Food productivity will be hit badly.<br />
* Food inflation will rise at an alarming rate.<br />
* Severe food crisis.<br />
* The intensity of unemployment problem<br />
will be increase.<br />
* Family problems, Social problems,<br />
Physiological problems.<br />
<strong>In</strong>dian <strong>Streams</strong> <strong>Research</strong> <strong>Journal</strong> / 115
<strong>Farmers</strong> <strong>Suicides</strong> <strong>In</strong> <strong>In</strong>dia Vol. 1, Issue . 1 / February 2011<br />
Remedies:<br />
<strong>Farmers</strong> need protection through<br />
protective legislation as nothing is typically<br />
done to help them settle their debts or tackle the<br />
unprecedented price rise that leads them to<br />
commit suicides. Mere lip sympathy by<br />
political parties and government officials is not<br />
enough to bridge the widening demand-supply<br />
gap in the agricultural sector.<br />
1. Minimum Support Price mechanism for<br />
agricultural produce should appropriate<br />
with consideration increase in agricultural<br />
inputs.<br />
2. <strong>In</strong>crease import duty on cotton: Tariff<br />
barriers should used to discourage import<br />
3. To integrate surface and groundwater<br />
irrigation schemes and integrate the line<br />
department in order that the schemes are<br />
implemented efficiently.<br />
4. Ensure that the formal banking system in<br />
the rural areas covers all the credit<br />
requirements of farmers and others, and<br />
that the coverage of the formal financial<br />
system is extended to all rural households.<br />
5. Set up a Distress Fund that will provide<br />
support to banks in chronically drought<br />
prone areas, and permit some debt relief to<br />
cultivators in extreme distress.<br />
6. Focus on increasing agricultural<br />
productivity with sustained growth and<br />
lower costs of production.<br />
7. Develop a land use strategy with particular<br />
reference to drought-prone areas.<br />
8. Promote and provide incentives for<br />
sustainable agriculture<br />
9. Identify input needs and monitor the<br />
provision of inputs to farmers<br />
10. Promote relevant public research in<br />
agriculture, particularly dry land<br />
agriculture, for the development of<br />
drought and disease resistant seeds of<br />
cereals and pulses.<br />
11. Analyze the relationship between input<br />
costs and market prices, and suggest<br />
appropriate and timely interventions by<br />
the state/central government agencies, in<br />
order to ensure remunerative prices to the<br />
farmers<br />
12. Monitor the adverse effects of droughts<br />
and pests on agriculture and bring in the<br />
required initiatives by the appropriate<br />
agencies to mitigate distress on account of<br />
these calamities.<br />
13. Oversee the settlement of land records,<br />
registration of all tenancies, and issue of<br />
passbooks to all cultivators including<br />
tenants.<br />
14. Improve infrastructure for crop markets<br />
and the post-harvest management of the<br />
produce<br />
15. Identify proper opportunities to promote<br />
rural employment, including nonfarm<br />
employment, encourage diversification<br />
within and out of agriculture; develop<br />
value addition activities such as agroprocessing<br />
in rural areas in a way that<br />
benefits farmers.<br />
16. Crop failures are a disaster for farmers and<br />
their families. Therefore government<br />
should make legal provision about crop<br />
insurance because they needy farmers<br />
<strong>In</strong>dian <strong>Streams</strong> <strong>Research</strong> <strong>Journal</strong> / 116
<strong>Farmers</strong> <strong>Suicides</strong> <strong>In</strong> <strong>In</strong>dia Vol. 1, Issue . 1 / February 2011<br />
take money from private lenders or banks<br />
or other finical institutions but when the<br />
crops fail, they are left with no option other<br />
than death.<br />
17. Set up a commission with statuary powers<br />
that takes decisions on the issues such as<br />
genetic modification technology and its<br />
impact on <strong>In</strong>dian agriculture, agriculture<br />
pricing policy and cropping pattern.<br />
18. Government should increase public<br />
expenditure on rural development .<br />
Bibliography<br />
1. Prasad C.V; Mathur V. Chatterjee-Sixty<br />
years of <strong>In</strong>dian Economy 1947 to<br />
2007,New Century Publication.New<br />
Delhi,2007<br />
2. Chandra S.P.-Economic Survey of <strong>In</strong>dia<br />
1947-48 to 2008-09, New Century<br />
Publication.New Delhi,2007<br />
4. Narendra Jadhav Report on <strong>Farmers</strong><br />
Suicide in Maharashtra, 2007<br />
5. Vandana Shiva-Why Are <strong>In</strong>dian <strong>Farmers</strong><br />
Committing Suicide & How can We Stop<br />
This Tragedy,www.voltairent.org-<br />
16/11/2010.<br />
6. Wakude S.M.-Suicide of farmers in<br />
Maharashtra-Causes & Remedies,<br />
www.nabard - 18/11/2010<br />
7. P.Sainath - www.indiatogther.org-<br />
3/11/2010<br />
8 . www.macroscan.org-15/11/2010<br />
9. www.un.org-2/11/2010<br />
10. The Hindu 2/2/2010<br />
3. Meeta And Rajivlochan-<strong>Farmers</strong> Suicide<br />
,YASHADA, Pune,2006<br />
<strong>In</strong>dian <strong>Streams</strong> <strong>Research</strong> <strong>Journal</strong> / 117