DALIT ONLINE – e News Weekly

Spreading the light of humanity & freedom

Editor: Nagaraja.M.R.. Vol.15..Issue.15........14 / 04 / 2019

The surprising silence on corporate corruption

- Pranjal Sharma

When will corporate India begin to talk about corruption within? When will it begin to
address the fraud that business leaders commit against investors, consumers and
employees?
Corruption within the government and political system is tackled by a framework of
checks and balances. Faulty and undermined it may be, but the framework does expose
scams and scandals at regular intervals.
Less regular is news about corporate corruption. Business leaders in India remain
surprisingly silent about the corrupt among them. Corporate corruption is of two kinds.
One where business leaders collaborate with rogue government and political leaders to
scam the exchequer or get ahead of rivals. This often gets exposed.
The second is where business leaders actively indulge in fraud against their stakeholders.
These include the consumers, investors and even employees.
While many would argue that this does not affect society at large, the truth is far scarier.
Most companies in India have borrowed from banks and financial institutions. These
funds belong to depositors and taxpayers.
So when a company commits a financial fraud it is really stealing the money from
investors, depositors or taxpayers. Sometimes from all. Scores of companies have been
accused of provident fund frauds. They take money from employees’ salaries but do not
deposit it in mandated provident fund. Most get away with it or hush up the matter.
Often the fraud is against consumers. This is the most dispersed category with little or no
organized strength.
Corporate India wants to believe that there is corruption everywhere except within itself.
It is a rare business leader who discusses corporate corruption openly. Most are part of
the millionaire society that has personal and filial links with each other.
As a result, none speaks against the other.
Industry bodies that are shrill about governance, tax and interest rate matters, remain
quiet. I can’t recall a conference organized by any domestic Indian industry body that
attacked corporate corruption.
There was a strange silence from corporate India when the Satyam scam was exposed.
Leading auditors, consultants and management consultants were implicated along with
the promoters of Satyam. Few business leaders spoke up against Ramalinga Raju, the
CEO and promoter who was indicted.
A similar silence was noted when the recent Ranbaxy case was exposed. Dinesh Thakur,
a US based senior executive of Ranbaxy Laboratories, complained against his own
company for falsifying drug data and risky manufacturing practices. He won the case
against his company and won $48 million under US law that protects whistleblowers.
Notice also the lack of reaction by corporate leaders against the Sahara Group that has
been accused by market regulator Securities and Exchange Board of India of stealing
money from depositors. Business leaders tend to look away in cases like and refuse to
even acknowledge it publicly.
The Indian system has two problems. One is that law does not protect whistleblowers
although a new bill is awaiting approval from parliament. Second is that business leaders
refuse to look the problem in the eye.
While legislative changes will take their course, it is time that business leaders begin to
look within. Captains of industry have to name and shame peers publicly much in the
same way they lament corruption in the government.

When will corporate India begin to talk about corruption within? When will it begin to
address the fraud that business leaders commit against investors, consumers and
employees?
Corruption within the government and political system is tackled by a framework of
checks and balances. Faulty and undermined it may be, but the framework does expose
scams and scandals at regular intervals.
Less regular is news about corporate corruption. Business leaders in India remain
surprisingly silent about the corrupt among them. Corporate corruption is of two kinds.
One where business leaders collaborate with rogue government and political leaders to
scam the exchequer or get ahead of rivals. This often gets exposed.
The second is where business leaders actively indulge in fraud against their stakeholders.
These include the consumers, investors and even employees.
While many would argue that this does not affect society at large, the truth is far scarier.
Most companies in India have borrowed from banks and financial institutions. These
funds belong to depositors and taxpayers.
So when a company commits a financial fraud it is really stealing the money from
investors, depositors or taxpayers. Sometimes from all. Scores of companies have been
accused of provident fund frauds. They take money from employees’ salaries but do not
deposit it in mandated provident fund. Most get away with it or hush up the matter.
Often the fraud is against consumers. This is the most dispersed category with little or no
organized strength.
Corporate India wants to believe that there is corruption everywhere except within itself.
It is a rare business leader who discusses corporate corruption openly. Most are part of
the millionaire society that has personal and filial links with each other.
As a result, none speaks against the other.
Industry bodies that are shrill about governance, tax and interest rate matters, remain
quiet. I can’t recall a conference organized by any domestic Indian industry body that
attacked corporate corruption.
There was a strange silence from corporate India when the Satyam scam was exposed.
Leading auditors, consultants and management consultants were implicated along with
the promoters of Satyam. Few business leaders spoke up against Ramalinga Raju, the
CEO and promoter who was indicted.
A similar silence was noted when the recent Ranbaxy case was exposed. Dinesh Thakur,
a US based senior executive of Ranbaxy Laboratories, complained against his own
company for falsifying drug data and risky manufacturing practices. He won the case
against his company and won $48 million under US law that protects whistleblowers.
Notice also the lack of reaction by corporate leaders against the Sahara Group that has
been accused by market regulator Securities and Exchange Board of India of stealing
money from depositors. Business leaders tend to look away in cases like and refuse to
even acknowledge it publicly.
The Indian system has two problems. One is that law does not protect whistleblowers
although a new bill is awaiting approval from parliament. Second is that business leaders
refuse to look the problem in the eye.
While legislative changes will take their course, it is time that business leaders begin to
look within. Captains of industry have to name and shame peers publicly much in the
same way they lament corruption in the government.

Editorial : CORPORATE CRIMINALS / CORPORATE TERRORISTS / TAX THIEVES RESPONSIBLE

FOR ALL ILLS IN INDIA

In India , a small shop owner to big industrialist have mastered the art of TAX EVASION . their
teachers - some corrupt tax officials & auditors. The black money thus created
is causing inflation, feeding the mafia , underworld. Some industrialists lobby ( bribe ) with the
government & gets favourable laws enacted. This black money is the main source of funds for
political parties , religious bodies & terrorist outfits.

The recent raids by C.B.I & KARNATAKA LOKAYUKTHA have proved how the tax officials have
become multi-millionaires. The sad part is that some of the police officials who are on deputation
to C.B.I & LOKAYUKTHA themselves are utterly corrupt.

This scourge can only be cured by corporate accountability intoto. However , all the industrialists
, traders who are demanding for more flexible labour reforms , economic reforms , infrastructure ,
etc are not at all concerned about their own accountability with respect to tax , environment ,
other laws. The MNCs coming to India are not coming here for best Indian talents or infrastructure
alone. In their own countries they are feeling the
heat of strict environment laws , consumer laws , share holder disclosures , corporate
accountability. Some of these MNCs are being kicked out of their countries , by it's own people
.These MNCs are aware that in India , by greasing the palms environment laws , labour laws , tax
laws , etc everything can be flouted , cases in courts can be dragged on for years . share holder
disclosures , corporate transparency is minimum.

However when a concerned citizen complains about the crimes of guilty corporates ,
organizations or corrupt public servants , immediate action is not taken. The file is kept pending
for months , years together , allowing the criminals to manipulate all the evidences , records ,
ground situations. Finally even if action is taken guilty will be let out due to favorable evidences ,
there are chances that the concerned citizen himself is falsely implicated & put behind bars . in all
such cases all the involved parties must be subjected to lie detector tests .

Bottomline : development is a must , it must be all around . but not at the cost of majority to make
a few richer.

Jai Hind. Vande Mataram.

Your’s sincerely,

Nagaraj.M.R.

Maruti Suzuki HR executive Murder , PRICOL VP MURDER , SATYAM CO FRAUD , SINGUR

AGITATION & GRAZIONO CEO MASS MURDER

- An eye opener to irresponsible corporate India & GOI

Few years ago, a senior HR executive of M/s Maruti Suzuki Ltd , Manesar , Haryana was burnt to
death by workers. Few Years back , in the state of tamilnadu India , some of the sacked
laboureres of M/S PRICOL INDUSTRIES mass lynched & murdered a higher management official ,
for sacking them from their jobs. This act of laborers is a heinous crime , illegal & inhuman act. In
India , nowadays the labour movement has been hijacked by lumpen elements , rowdies ,
criminals. These criminal elements are there in the posts of union leaders just to further their self
interests rather than the welfare of the workers whom they represent. These lumpen elements , so
called leaders thrive on controversies & creates disturbances , vitiates harmonious relations
between the management – workers. The company as an organization needs team work to survive
& thrive in business. These labor leaders even oppose for example OUTPUT BASED
PRODUCTION INCENTIVE SCHEME – which is a win win situation for both the management &
workers. These leaders go to the extent of killing the hen which lays golden eggs , all for their
selfish gains. These rowdy leaders become leaders just to make money , to make political entry ,
to shirk-off work , to escape night shift work , etc. In the midst of these rowdy elements the
genuine concerns of ordinary workers are not at all heard. The ordinary workers who depend on
the organization for their livelihood , who work hard to earn more incentive , are the ultimate
sufferers.

In the same manner , the management of companies must be sensible to the genuine concerns
of it's workers , it must properly balance the worker's concern & company's position . some of the
managements enforce harsh rules on workers , o.k , the management personnel of those very
same companies function without discipline , misuse company properties , siphons of company
money , take commission from vendors , cheat the government of tax dues , violate environmental
laws , tax laws , labor laws by bribing officials , etc. Finally this kills the organization as a whole –
the end losers shareholders , lending banks , government & our economy.

Few years back the public agitation at singur west Bengal , India against the TATA NANO project
, was nothing but a struggle for survival by the land loosers. Ofcourse ultimately Tata shifted
their nano project site. The public of singur are living there since ancestral times , they fully
depend for their livelihood on the vegetables & other small crops grown there by them. The
livelihood , their survival is at stake. The irresponsible west Bengal government , to favour the
corporate lobby , acquired the lands forcibly dirt cheap & gave it away at dirt cheap price to
TATA'S. why such a cheap , long term lease period has been given to TATA'S ? The government
literally has thrown the land loosers on street , it didn't bother about their survival nor about their
proper rehabilitation . Basically , TATA'S is a business house , their only intention is to make
profits , more money , not the welfare of people. Why not TATA'S acquire land in open market ?
the acquire of lands by state or central government for public good like for building dams , roads
, channels are at least justified however the rehabilitation is more important. Other than for the
projects concerning public good , for all the projects of private enterprises like pay & use roads ,
airports , industries , etc , the lands must be acquired in the open market at market prices . For
some industrialists bid to make riches , lives , livelihood of thousands should not be sacrificed. It
is not alround development. In a democracy , the voice of the public , locals should be honoured
but not the diktats of ministers or babus in secretariats. The present corrupt system in India
leading to rise of naxalism , underworld , separatist movements are all due to the government
policies since independence till date according to the wisdom (?) of ministers & babus , totally
dishonouring the public voice.

Now , take the case of Graziono CEO mass murder in noida , it is nothing but fallout of hire & fire
policies. Every human being works for survival , on his meager salary there will be family
dependents , all of a sudden if a person is fired from service , his whole family will be on streets.
O.k , all corporates nowadays preach & breath the mantra of USA , for everything be it
infrastructure , flexible labour policies , it compares itself with those prevailing in the USA. Now ,
the corporate India is getting infrastructure at dirt free prices ( very high in the USA ) , has got hire
& fire mechanism by employing contract labour , very lenient environmental norms , very lenient
food & drugs safety rules , relaxation in Factory Act , ESI & PF acts , etc add to it the rampant
corruption in all govt departments by which you can get any certificate for a price.

In the USA , of course there is hire & fire policy , however the minimum wage levels are also very
high , so that during good times workers can save money for their future. Also , there is social
security net to take care of ousted workers , then why not Indian corporates paying good salary to
workers during good times ? why not corporate India making good contribution to social security
net ? in the USA , there are good infrastructure facilities they take pride in paying taxes to the
government , the corporate India always lobbies for tax cuts , subsidies , loan waivers , etc. in the
USA the environment norms are very strict , the companies manufacturing hazardous chemicals
which were ousted by the US government have set up shop in India . Government of USA treats
lives of people as precious , where as Indian government treats lives of it's people as dispensable.
In the USA , the food safety & drugs , medicines safety standards are very high , the drugs , high
level adulteration food products banned by Government of USA are sold in the India , this is the
difference between government of USA & India , the way they treat their people's lives. Loan
recovery , investor safety norms are very high in the USA , where as in India , loan defaulters ,
share holder swindling , Non Performing Assets is very high. Inspite of all the strict norms we
have seen enron , Xerox debacles in the USA & recent bank fallouts in the USA. In India with such
lax norms , only you can guess.

The lesson here for the government of India is , development must be allround , must not be at the
cost of thousands. Listen to the voice of public but not to the commands of greedy selfish
corporates , lobbies . Do stop thinking that only babus , IAS officers & minister are brilliant
knowing all and the public people are fools fit to be herded by IAS officers. Do remember that
India is a democracy not a BANANA REPUBLIC.

The lesson for corporate India , aping the USA intoto is O.k , but not by parts & bits , follow
corporate USA in every aspect of corporate duties & responsibilities , transparency.

Final word , when it comes to the question of survival , life , livelihood , it know no bounds . After
all STRUGGLE FOR SUVIVAL is a basic animal instinct , it is a basic human right of every
individual .
CORPORATE ACCOUNTABILITY IN INDIA

CORPORATE ACCOUNTABILITY Scandals related to the appalling practices of multinational

corporations like Union Carbide (now DOW), Enron, Coke, Cadbury, and
others may have shocked the nation and the world in the recent past, but the media rarely
highlights corporate crimes that extend to murders, destroying habitats, threatening indigenous
cultures, causing disease, contaminating the planet's food supply, poisoning
our groundwater and even destroying the very air we breathe.

You think this is an exaggeration? Well consider this. In Bhopal, India more than 8,000 people
died in the first three days after 40 tonnes of lethal gas spilled out from Union Carbide's pesticide
factory in December 1984. People woke in their homes to fits of coughing, their lungs filling with
fluid. 520,000 people were exposed to poisonous gases. 150,000 victims are chronically ill, and
even now one person dies every two days. Union Carbide merged with Dow Chemical Corporation
two years ago and has ceased to exist as an entity while the present owners Dow refuse to accept
any pending liabilities in Bhopal including clean-up of the abandoned site.

In Kodaikanal, India, Hindustan Lever, a subsidiary of Unilever Plc, an Anglo-Dutch multinational

dumped mercury waste from its thermometer factory in the surrounding forests and on an
innocent local community. When the scandal was exposed, first the company denied that there
was a problem and later fudged facts and figures until the Indian authorities forced them to come
clean. Since then Unilever has retrieved and sent back to USA some of the waste for disposal but
are shying away from compensating affected workers and further environmental remediation
measures.

Monsanto, one of the world's largest pesticide companies, continues to sell its genetically
engineered seeds to farmers around the world despite growing evidence of failure of crops like Bt
cotton, that has reduced once well-to-do farmers in the developing world to penury and poverty
while the threat of contamination of indigenous species by GE
seeds increases everyday.

Bayer AG, a German transnational continues to manufacture and sell phased out pesticides like
Methyl Parathion (brand name Folidol/Metacid) in Asia despite an assurance to their European
investors and stake holders that they would stop manufacturing these organo-phosphate poisons.

Ship-owning companies (and indeed, their countries) like Bergesen (Norway), and Chandris
(Greece) meanwhile, regularly violate international and national laws and dump their hazardous
wastes at ship-breaking yards in India, Pakistan, China, Turkey and Bangladesh. The voluntary
guidelines issued by International Marine Organisation
are not enough and it is imperative that these guidelines are made mandatory to make the ship-
owners liable and responsible.

In the era of globalization, multinational companies increasingly move around assets, products
and wastes on a global chessboard to maximize their profits and minimize their costs. These
companies are using differences and loopholes in national environmental and health laws for
example to export pesticides and destructive technologies to
poorer countries to the detriment of local communities. What international body oversees them, or
sets rules for their behaviour, or holds them accountable when they transgress?

It is no longer just the conspiracy theorists who believe our world is increasingly ruled and ruined
by large multinational corporations. The World Trade Organisation has supplanted environmental
treaties and regulations. Corporations have become accountable only under the rules of a free
market, free trade and a free for all on human rights and the environment.

The state of our environment has not improved, in fact it has deteriorated. The gap between the
world's rich and poor has widened. Instead of providing developing countries with the tools for
sustainable development, corporations have pushed their dirty
technologies and polluting industries on to some of the world's poorest countries.

A recent UN report revealed that Exxon, with $63 billion, is worth more than Peru or New Zealand.
General Electric more than Kuwait. Shell is worth more than Morocco or Cuba.

In the past ten years, corporations have not only resisted

environmental challenges, they have lobbied to water down
international treaties and even succeeded in getting countries to
pull out of environmental agreements altogether. They have maintained
their unsustainable practices in all sectors. It is apparent that
more than just voluntary measures are needed to control these
corporations.

A recent report by WWF states that if we continue at current levels

of consumption we will use up all of the Earth's resources within 50
years, and we will need two more planets to meet our resource needs.
We either take urgent action to save the planet, or we get off.
The UN Environmental Programme agrees that "the state of the planet
is getting worse." They say "there is a growing gap between the
efforts of business and industry to reduce their impact on the
environment and the worsening state of the planet."

At the root of our environmental problems are the unsustainable

practices of the corporations that shape our economies. But what is
the good of a short-term healthy economy if we can't drink the water,
eat the foods in the fields or breathe the air?

Current systems of governance in Asia (as elsewhere) are proving to

be deficient against the activities of abusive multinational
corporations. To roll back the excessive powers of corporations and
to pressure governments to check corporate abuse and prosecute
corporate crimes, greater public participation is a must. The Rainbow
Warrior's Corporate Accountability Tour of India is part of a global
movement to change the climate of opinion against abusive
corporations and to turn the tide in favour of fundamental human
rights.

Corporations need to be held accountable for their actions that are

destroying the planet, destroying people's lives around the globe.
There is only one answer. We must stand up to the corporations. Our
governments must agree on international, legally binding rules for
corporate responsibility, accountability and liability: a set of
rules that business must follow, and governments must enforce.
The list of rules is long, but so are the crimes.

The world needs corporations to be held accountable to the following

laws – no matter where they operate in the world. HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH
is calling upon the Indian Government to endorse the Bhopal
Principles on Corporate Responsibility, which call on Multinational
Corporations to:
• Accept liability for environmental damage and compensate victims of
pollution;
• Accept liability for the damage, no matter when it happens, what
the cause or who in the corporation is responsible;
• Accept responsibility for damage and injury beyond national borders
including accidents in the oceans and atmosphere;
• Ensure that they do not infringe upon basic human rights;
• Disclose all information regarding releases into the environment to
the public;
• Protect human and social rights including the highest standards for
rights to health care and a clean environment;
• Avoid influence over governments, combat bribery and practice
transparency;
• Allow states to maintain their sovereignty over their own food
supply;
• Implement a precautionary principle and take preventative action
before environmental damages or health effects are incurred; and
• Promote and practice clean and sustainable development

CORPORATE FRAUDS IN INDIA

Corporate fraud is nothing new to india , satyam company is just a new addition to it. Satyam co
was able to commit such a huge fraud & keep it under wraps for years goes to prove the honesty ,
integrity of our public servants , government officials belonging to SEBI , RBI , tax dept , pollution
control , labour depts. , etc & the honesty of auditors & company secretaries. Ofcourse , still
there are few honest people in public service , auditing & company secretaryship , but majority of
them are hand in gloves with corporate criminals. Definitely , this fraud will also be brushed under
the carpet after certain time as other frauds happened , afterall these frauds are the money
spinners for political party funding , mafia , underworld & other criminal activities.

IN INDIA , government reports , records , everything can be bought for a price. During Karnataka
lokayukta raids huge wealth amounting crores of rupees were found with each of the corrupt
government officials like police , engineers , tax officials , etc. How those government officials
with few thousands of salary earn so much , by compromising with their government duties ,
by creating fake government reports , records , etc . The government & the courts of justice treat
those government reports , as sacrosanct like TEN COMMANDMENTS DIRECTLY FROM THE
MOUTH OF GOD HIMSELF.

The CORPORATE CRIMINALS & RICH CRIMINALS buy favourable government reports , records
from the government officials commit bigger crimes , escapes from legal prosecution by proving
their innocence , honesty with the aid of BOUGHT GOVERNMENT REPORTS & RECORDS. The
courts of justice lacks broad vision , it has only narrow vision as a riding horse's vision is
narrowed . courts of justice is only bothered about technicalities , evidences , records , it lacks
the spirit of QUEST FOR TRUTH , it lacks truth finding mechanism out of massive reports ,
records , evidences. The rich criminals are in a position to manipulate , buy out evidences ,
government reports , so definitely they will escape from hook. Today , I can convincingly state
that our legal system is such that , even the terrorists who attacked our TEMPLE OF DEMOCRACY
- THE INDIAN PARLIAMENT will be let free , when they can fully buyout evidences , reports , etc.

In this backdrop , the corporates technically maintain clean public image although privately they
are frauds , criminals. If anybody makes a statement of truth against them , those corporate
criminals will slap defamatory & other criminal charges against such persons. The courts of
justice upholds the claims of not the speaker of truth but the corporate criminals , on the basis
of bought evidences , government reports. The courts doesn't go into the truthfulness of those
reports , evidences & sends the speaker of truth to prison. If any person has made any
complaints of fraud against Satyam Co , two months back he would have definitely faced criminal
prosecution & jail term. As all the records , auditor reports , company secretary report , reports
of ministry of company affairs , reports of tax departments , everything was in it's favour. The
courts are only bothered about evidences , records which were all in satyam's favour , the courts
are least bothered about quest for truth & justice. In this manner in India , there are hordes of
private companies where frauds have taken place & taking place & wiil be.

Just recently after Ramalinga raju's own statement , does it became public that the reports of
auditor , company secretary , related governmet records are all false. Base linbe everything was
bought. Do remember that whether it is SATYAM FRAUD , ENRON SCAM or XEROX SCAM , those
were not found , revealed either by our investigating agencies or the government. Satyam's Fraud
came to light due to pressure created by the recession , market forces on the company's promoter
Mr.RAMALINGA RAJU & his resultant confession , Enron scam was unearthed by US
investigators in USA during the corse of their investrigation , It is the same with XEROX Co . till
those revealations , those companies were good , legally abiding cos in govt records. THAT
MEANS THEY HAVE BOUGHT OUT INDIAN LEGAL SYSTEM EFFECTIVELY.
In this manner , in India most of the entrpreneurs small shop owners to big corporates buy out tax
officials , labour department officials , pollution control board officials , etc & openly indulge in
unfair , illegal trade practices , labour practices , legal violations , etc , still go unpunished , as as
per book , the government records they are law abiding , persons , corporates.

Entrepreneurs , promoters of big corporations collect public money either through shares ,
debentures , bank loans or all . so ideally public are also stake holders in such companies . The
criminal entrpreneures , promoters siphon-off companies resources in various ways like selling
company assets to their sister cos at a lesser value or purchasing assets from sister cos at a
higher value , giving loans to sister cos at low interest rate or taking loans from sister cos at
higher interest rate , etc. in this way they siphon-off resources of public companies / enterprises
with bank loans to their own family owned sister cos. We at e-voice of human rights of watch are
ready to catch such corporate criminals & help the government , ofcourse subject to conditions ,
are you ready ?

In india , tax compliance is worse. In our criminal justice system, there is rigorous imprisonment
for a pick-pocketer stealing Rs.10. even the authorities spend thousands of rupees in legally
prosecuting him & the thief spends a year or more as punishment behind bars. Where as there is
no commensurate investigation nor legal prosecution nor punishment for corporate thieves ,
evading tax to the tune of crores of rupees. In contrast, those tax thieves pay a part of that booty
to the ministers & political parties and get crores of rupees tax exemptions , incentives from the
government. Government is rewarding corporate criminals.

The tax officials of central & state governments are hand in glove with these corporate
criminals & traders. For a price, they are helping corporates & traders in evading tax. Most of the
tax officials are wealthy & leading luxurious lifestyles , much beyond the scope of their legal
income. The black money thus generated every year by tax evasion , is many times more than our
total annual budget allocation. As a result, all our fiscal reforms fail & inflation is soaring. This
black money is the source of illegal funding of political parties , terrorist outfits & underworld. It is
a greater threat to national unity & integrity.

Both the central government & karnataka state government have failed to collect the
full , actual tax dues from corporates & traders. As a result , the governments don't have enough
money in their coffers even to provide basic needs like health care , education , safe drinking
water , etc to the poor & needy. For every Rs.100 tax evaded , one poor patient is dying without
medical care , 10 poor persons lack education , 100 persons don't get safe drinking water , 100
persons barely survive on a single piece meal per day , 20 persons starve. Most of The
government officials , ministers & people's representatives who have deliberately failed in their
duties of tax collection & welfare of poor citizens , SHAMELESSLY indulge in luxurious lifestyle at
the expense of poor tax payer . they live in paltial bungalows , chauffer driven AC cars , all living
food expenses paid by exchequer , dine at 5-star hotels , only drink bottled mineral water , eat
non-vegetarian dishes , drink alcohol sitting before mahatma gandhi's photograph & preaching
mahatma's ideals. Mahatma preached & practiced simple living , vegetarianism & he was teto
teller , he paid for his expenses from his earnings . these public servants are parasites , who are
making merry at the expense of tax payer.

Some non government organisations ( NGO) have formed trusts and under the aegis
of those trusts are running educational institutions , hospitals , community halls , etc , in the
name of providing free / subsidised services like education , health care , etc to the poor. It is only
in record books , they conduct fake medical camps , self employment training camps . in practice
they are running these educational institutions , hospitals & community halls as commercial
enterprises & collecting huge fees. they are not even remitting full fees collected to the trust
account & swindling the money. no outsider is allowed to become a member of these NGOs , only
their cronies & their family members are in these trusts.

Numerous NGOs promoted by religious bodies , mutts are swindling public &
government money to the tune of crores of rupees. Nobody dares to question the heads , pontiffs
of these mutts , as at his feet VVIPs , ministers fall down. These religious bodies are hot beds of
fundamentalism , terrorism & mafia. Hwere is the accountability of religious bodies & political
parties in in india ?

Inspite of bringing specific cases to the notice of authorities , they are mum ? hereby ,
E-VOICE OF HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH offers it's services ( subject to conditions ) to the
governments of india & karnataka , in apprehending the criminals – tax evaders. Are you ready mr.
singh sir & mr.Yediyurappa sir ? If you are ready to do your duty look into the following cases ,
take appropriate action & kindly inform me about the outcome.

WHY MULTINATIONAL COMPANIES ARE INVESTING IN INDIA?

We condemn the brutal massacre by police on farmers – who are going to loss all their lands ,
sources.of livelihood for the sake of special economic zones , industrial parks , etc in various
states of India.

In every mega projects undertaken by government , both the state government & central
government have functioned like REAL ESTATE / COMMISSION AGENTS for the rich & mighty .
the government says it is acquiring lands for development of industries , for public good. In reality
there is only good of rich & mighty.

For forming S.E.Zs , corporates gets speedy single window approvals from government , lands at
concessional rates – lower than market value , soft loans from Indian banks , tax exemptions for
years from the government , dedicated power supply , etc , from the government . these
corporates are even given free hand to raise share capital in the Indian market. the government
has enacted flexible labour laws specifically for S.E.Zs , they can hire & fire without bothering to
pay gratuity , etc and they are exempted from providing P.F / E.S.I coverage to their employees ie
they need not worry about the occupational health hazards of their employees , they can employ
them till they are fit & throw them on streets afterwards. These corporates take our own
money, employ our own people , use our own natural resources & finally take away the net
profits to their home countries – what they give back ? – environmental pollution , tax evasions ,
low paid occupational hazardous jobs to locals , stock market scams .

During Previous License Regime foreign, investment was not directly welcome in India. As people
at that time perceived it as "Neo colonisation" & detested it. There were various restrictions on
foreign investments. The local industrialists under monopolistic
environment thrived, who were no way better than day light robberers, of course with a few
exception. Under the political patronage, the cunning industrialists looted public money, cheated
the government of tax, cheated lending banks & cheated the investors
too. They easily flouted labour laws & made labourers to work in inhuman conditions.

During 1990's under the international pressure India signed GATT & slowly started opening it's
economy. Now, from 01/01/05 even product patent has come into force in India. Are MNCs
bringing high technology intensive industries to India? No, not at all. They are actually denying
sophisticated technologies to India. They are only
bringing the FMCG industries - salt, chips, ketch-up, colas, for which India is a huge home market.
They are into services like Hotels, medical care, marketing. In other cases, they are just marketing
the products manufactured at their bases in U.S.A. or Europe.

They are not bringing in new production technologies in the areas like space research, nuclear
energy, bio-technology, pharmaceuticals or pollution control, to India. Also, some MNCs are
relocating their highly polluting industries to India, as they are subjected to stringent
environmental protection standards in their own home countries. Whereas, In India the
Government is highly corrupt & can be bought for a price. The attractive points for foreign direct
investment (FDI) in India are,

1. There is lack of comprehensive environmental norms.

2. The enforcement of environmental norms is lax.

3. The cost of health coverage, social security net to be provided to the workers exposed to the
occupational hazards is less.

4. The cost of compensation to be paid to the persons-who died or suffered damages due to
occupational hazards/environmental pollution is meager.

5. The enforcement of labour laws are lax.

6. Public money can be easily raised through lending Banks, primary market within India & the
public can be easily cheated.

7. The tax can be evaded through various loopholes like transferring money to holding companies
situated at Mauritius or countries which have double taxation avoidance agreement with India.

8. The tax can be evaded, company money can be cheated by lending money to sister / holding
concerns at low interest rates or by selling shares, materials to their private companies at low
rates or by buying shares, materials from their holding/sister concerns at exhorbitant rates, etc.
9. The corporate governance laws are almost absent in India & it's enforcement nil.

10. Above all, the time can be bought by very slow Indian legal system, if any dispute arise.

11. On top of it, well trained, technically qualified people are available at low rates through
contractors.

Just consider the following cases which highlight the apathy, irresponsibility of government of
India and emboldened the cunning, MNCs:-

1. The India which boasts of so much scientific/technological advancements, is till date has been
unable to provide potable water to it's people. People of west Bengal , Karnataka , Andrapradesh
states are forced to drink Arsenic, Fluoride poisoned water.

2. The people living near the mines of R.E.M.P. in Kerala are suffering due to exposure to the radio
active materials, Same is the case with the people of Jadaguda, Jharkhand, living near the U.C.I.L.
plant. Both M/S R.E.M.P & M/s U.C.I.L are department of atomic energy enterprises.

3. Few years back, In Mysore railway station containers of radio- active materials were left
unattended. The dome of reactor building at construction stage collapsed in nuclear power plant
at Kaiga. A fire tragedy occurred in Kakrapar nuclear power plant. In the recent Tsunami waves
onslaught, certain important facilities of Koodakulam atomic plant were damaged near Chennai.

4. In 1984, U.S. based MNC union carbide mass murdered nearly 20,000 people, injured lakhs who
are still suffering health problems. The polluted poisonous accident site i.e. Union carbide plant in
Bhopal is not yet cleared off toxic materials even after 20 years.
This is still further damaging the residents of Bhopal.

5. In the above union carbide disaster, the Government of India didn't present the case properly
before supreme courts of India & U.S.A.. As a result the MNC just paid a pittance as
compensation. As per that the cost of Indian lives are just a fraction of cost of
American lives. Just imagine if a same disaster occurred in U.S.A. at the plant of a MNC
headquartered in India, what would have been the consequence?

6. In India, hazardous chemicals laced with food additives are passed through the drinks,
beverages like pepsi, cola, coco cola very easily.

7. The medicines like nimesulide, paracetamol, etc. with hazardous side effects which are banned
in U.S.A.& Europe, are easily marketed by the same U.S.& Europe based MNCs in India.

8. In India spurious drugs, medicines, food stuffs are easily marketed.

9. In India, the clinical trials of new medicines under research are done without proper
compensation structure to those being tried upon ie. Virtual guinea pigs.

10. In India, the genetically engineered BT crops are being introduced without paying attention to
formers, ecology or eco-system.

11. In India, during setting up of large projects, scant attention is paid to environment, eco-system
& the displaced persons.

Most of the times, in government projects itself the displaced persons are cheated by the
government in numerous ways.

12. In India, various Government as well as private hospitals dumps hospital wastes with deadly
viruses in the open, with scant regard to public health.

13. In India, aged ships belonging to foreign countries are breaked down to scrap in ship breaking
yards of Gujarath , Maharashtra & AP. Various toxins like the Asbestos, lead, etc & the hazardous,
dirty water, Oil inside the ship are drained into Indian seashore. The labourers here are forced to
work without any safety gears.

14. When specific cases of human rights violations were brought before the government &
Judiciary by us , both of them didn't respond at all.

All the above cases highlight the fact that, government of India & Indian judiciary treats it's
citizens lives as cheap, dispensable at will. This is the major attracting force for MNCs to India.

Edited, printed , published owned by NAGARAJA.M.R. @ # LIG-2 No 761, HUDCO FIRST STAGE , OPP
WATER WORKS , LAXMIKANTANAGAR , HEBBAL ,MYSURU – 570017 KARNATAKA INDIA Cell : 91
8970318202
WhatsApp 91 8970318202

Home page :
http://eclarionofdalit.dalitonline.in/

https://dalit-online.blogspot.com
Contact : editor@dalitonline.in , editor.dalitonline@gmail.com