Academia.eduAcademia.edu
TH W EM RI TI ATI N C GS L'HISTOIRE THE FORGOTTEN VICTIMS AND THEIR CASTE QUESTION: A SOCIO-HISTORICAL TRAJECTORY OF BENGAL’S DALIT REFUGEES OISHIKA GHOSH - “History has never written their story of facing impossible odds to fight, with their lifeblood, to the very bitter end, for survival”. (Shaktipada Rajguru. (1980). ‘Dandak Theke Marichjhapi’) The Partition of India, irrespective of its multidimensional connotations, asserts possibly the most dubious terrain of South Asian historiography, today. Though Indian National Congress, with its penchant for a centralized unitary state, accepted Partition as a necessary price; Bengal has shown us how the Hindu Bhadralok elite spearheaded the formation of a Hindu-majority province. The question remains, can the movement for Partition then be claimed as an elite affair? Studies on Bengal (Hashmi 1992) proclaimed that not only was it an elite affair with a long afterlife, but the historiography of Partition through the lens of Dalits has remained invisible and forgotten. Speaking of which, the renowned Indian feminist writer Urvashi Butalia asserts, ‘In its almost exclusive focus on Hindus, Sikhs and Muslims, Partition history has worked to render many others invisible. One such history is that of the scheduled castes, or untouchables’ (Butalia, 2000: 235). Ranging from the Tehbhaga sharecropper’s movement in 1940s to the Naxalite movement of the 1970s, each of these movements have engraved their marks on the life of Bengal’s citizens. The plunders of partition: The migration of Namasudra lower-caste refugees from Dandakaranya to Marichjhapi, and their ensuing extermination, is considered JULY 2022 PG NO : 17 L'HISTOIRE to be one of the worst instances of statesponsored violence on Bengal’s refugees to date. From a 21st-century standpoint, the brutal massacre at Marichjhapi can be labeled as nothing short of the annihilation of Dalits. Debjani Sengupta rightly points out that Marichjhapi is, by all means, the poison tree which continues to bear strange fruits (Sengupta, 2018), and perhaps will continue to do so. Going through the pages of history, one thing rests assured. The arrival of the Dalit refugees years after 1947 became a catastrophe of reintegration that West Bengal had not faced before. While the Namasudras started moving into Bengal after the assurance of minister Ram Chatterjee, an idea started gaining its ground that all the newcomers should be housed and accommodated outside West Bengal. Interestingly, while Dalits and their identity politics remain forgotten and invisible, Marichjhapi is almost an un-forgotten chapter. Speaking of Bengal’s Dalit refugees and their historiography, one can never ignore the silence surrounding the Marichjhapi massacre. Marichjhapi: a nightmare for the refuge problem in Bengal : Ram Chatterjee, the then Left Front minister, visited the refugee camps at Dandakaranya and encouraged the refugees to settle in parts of the Sunderbans. Promised land and prosperity, families sold their lands and started moving towards Marichjhapi. But the Left Government of Bengal, undergoing rapid changes in its mode of governance and ideology, declared Marichjhapi as a reserved forest and painted the refugees as disruptive elements, violating the Indian Forest Acts. On January 26, 1979, the Left Front chief minister Jyoti Basu announced an economic blockade of Marichjhapi. The refugees were tear-gassed and brutally tortured, their huts and fisheries were destroyed, and tube wells were poisoned. Legend has it that the Royal Bengal Tigers of Sundarbans became maneaters after they feasted on the bodies of the people killed at Marichjhapi. Are we turning into a state of terror? Practically, the present-day problem with the citizenship status of Bengali Dalit refugees ‘The Forgotten Massacre of Dalit Refugees in West Bengal's Marichjhapi’ - The Wire. Retrieved from https://thewire.in/history/westbengal-violence-marichjhapi-dandakaranya JULY 2022 PG NO : 18 L'HISTOIRE started ever since 2003 when the Citizenship (Amendment) Act of 2003 was passed. The Act soon led to the arrests of refugees who were termed 'illegal migrants' in West Bengal. While the Left Front government had successfully covered up the massacre of Dalit Refuges at Marichjhapi, it seems to be even more unfortunate that the citizenship issue of refugees, including those who survived Marichjhapi, is still buried even under the Mamata Banerjee-led Trinamool Congress administration. Although the Matua Mahasangha (MM), launched a movement demanding “unconditional citizenship rights” and rehabilitation for Bengali refugees residing in India, the Dalit refugees in West Bengal continue to live in a state of terror and turmoil, till date. Conclusion: Why do we need to study Marichjhapi, through the lens of Bengal’s refugee problem today? The Marichjhapi massacre did no harm to the pro-poor image of the Left front. Standing in today’s Bengal, where the refugee problem remains unsettled till date, Marichjhapi has become nothing but a footnote. Though several newspaper reports have been published around the massacre, none of them have led to much uproar. Digging in the course of events and history behind Marichjhapi, it has come up to prove everything that was wrong with the then governmental authority of Bengal on the cusp of independence and the movement for Partition. JULY 2022 References: • Sengupta, Debjani. (2018). ‘The Forgotten Massacre of Dalit Refugees in West Bengal's Marichjhapi’ - The Wire. Retrieved from https://thewire.in/history/west-bengalviolence-marichjhapi-dandakaranya • Mandal, Dilip. (15 May 2019) ‘40 Yrs Ago, the Left Mercilessly Massacred Dalit Bengalis. Now, It’s Back to Haunt Them The Print’. Retrieved from theprint.in/opinion/40-yrs-ago-the-leftmercilessly-massacred-dalit-bengalis-nowits-back-to-haunt-them/235648. • Rajguru, Shaktipada. (1980). ‘Dandak Theke Marichjhapi’. India. • Ainslie, T. Embree. & Taj ul-Islam, Hashmi. (1993). ‘Pakistan as a Peasant Utopia: The Communalization of Class Politics in East Bengal’. The American Historical Review. Volume 98, Issue 3, June. Pages 930–931, https://doi.org/10.1086/ahr/98.3.930-a • Butalia, Urvashi. (2000). ‘The Other Side of Silence: Voices from the Partition of India’. Penguin Books: India. Pp. 235 PG NO : 19